Name: Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich (Easy, Cheesy, and So Good)
Prep time: 5 min
Cook time: 10 min
Total time: 15 min
Yield: 4
Cuisine: american
Ingredients: 1.5 oz softened cream cheese; 1 cup shredded extra sharp cheddar; 1 cup shredded mozzarella; 1/4 cups real mayonnaise; 3/4 cup diced dill pickles; 1 tsp dill weed; 1 tsp garlic salt; 1/4 tsp black pepper; 8 thick slices of your favorite bread (we prefer sourdough!); Butter for grilling outside of sandwiches

Jump to Recipe

This is the most DILL-ightful Grilled Cheese!I apologize for the corny pickle pun… actually no I don’t. Who can help themselves when it comes to a pickle pun?

This easy dill pickle grilled cheese sandwich is a dream come true for pickle lovers. It’s loaded with melty cheese, tangy dill pickles, and all the cozy comfort food vibes you want in a quick meal. Especially during Lent, this one is on repeat at our house.

If you’ve never put dill pickles in a grilled cheese before, you’re seriously missing out. The combo of gooey cheese and that bright, tangy crunch is next level. Once you try it, a regular grilled cheese kind of feels boring.

Why You’ll Love This Pickle Grilled Cheese

Quick and easy to make
Super cheesy with a tangy pickle bite
Easy to customize with different cheeses or add ins
Perfect for lunch, dinner, or late night cravings

This is one of those recipes that feels a little fun but still totally comforting.

Best Cheese for Pickle Grilled Cheese

You can keep this classic or mix things up. Cheddar is always a solid choice for a sharp, melty grilled cheese. Havarti, Monterey Jack, or Swiss also work really well.

If you want to get a little wild, try adding crispy bacon, a swipe of spicy mustard, or even a sprinkle of ranch seasoning.

I highly recommend shredding your own cheese. It’s fresher, melts better, and doesn’t have the extra coatings that pre shredded cheese does. We shred all of our cheese and this electric cheese grater is a lifesaver. Totally worth it.

What Kind of Bread Works Best

You want a sturdy bread that can handle all that cheesy, pickley goodness without falling apart. Sourdough, Texas toast, or a rustic artisan loaf are all great options for a pickle grilled cheese sandwich.

How to Make a Dill Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Cooking tip: Go low and slow with the heat. Let the bread toast gradually so it turns golden brown while the cheese melts all the way through. High heat can burn the outside before the inside is ready, and no one wants that.

Instructions:

Combine all of the ingredients except for the bread and butter into a bowl.

2. Spread a layer of your mixture on your bread. Then top it with another slice of bread.

3. Spread butter on the outside of your sandwich and grill in a skillet on medium heat. You want to cook this low and slow so all the cheesy awesomeness has time to heat through. After the first side is browned to your liking, flip and continue cooking on the other side.

Now your sandwich is ready for you to enjoy!!!

Serving Ideas

This sandwich isn’t just for lunch. It’s great for easy dinners or when you need comfort food without making a mess.

Serve it with tomato soup, kettle chips, or a simple green salad if you’re feeling fancy. It also makes a great quick meal on busy nights.

FAQ

Can you put pickles in grilled cheese?
Yes, and it’s really good. Dill pickles add a tangy crunch that balances the richness of melted cheese perfectly.

What pickles are best for grilled cheese?
Dill pickles work best. Look for ones that are crisp and not overly sweet.

Can I make this ahead of time?
Grilled cheese is best served fresh, but you can prep the ingredients ahead to make it quick and easy when you’re ready to cook.

More Grilled Cheese Recipes to Try

If you’re looking for another out of the box grilled cheese recipe, check out my French Onion Grilled Cheese Sandwich. It combines your favorite soup flavors with classic grilled cheese comfort.

This post contains affiliate links.